Math Magic is a web site devoted to
original mathematical recreations. If you have a math puzzle, discovery, or observation, please e-mail me about it. You can also send answers to the problem of the month. |

Math Magic Archive |

This model is easy to analyze for 2 players. If player 1 chooses x≤1/2, player 2 chooses x+2ε, and the scores are x+ε and 1–x–ε respectively. If player 1 chooses x≥1/2, player 2 chooses x–2ε, and the scores will be 1–x+ε and x–ε respectively. Thus player 1 chooses 1/2 and player 2 chooses 1/2±2ε, and the scores will be 1/2+ε and 1/2–ε.

The 3 player case is more complicated. If player 1 chooses x≤1/4, player 2 chooses (1–x)/3, and player 3 chooses any number between them in the interval (x, (1–x)/3). In this case the average scores will be (5x+1)/6, (1–x)/3, and (1–x)/2 respectively. If player 1 chooses 1/4<x≤1/2, then player 2 chooses 1–x+2ε and player 3 chooses x–2ε. In this case the scores will be 1/2–x+2ε, 1/2-ε, and x–ε respectively. The cases where player 1 chooses x≥1/2 are similar by symmetry. Thus player 1 chooses 1/4, player 2 chooses 3/4, and player 3 chooses something between in the interval (1/4,3/4), giving average scores of 3/8, 3/8, and 1/4. What are the best strategies for more than 3 players?

This game is also interesting where players get multiple turns in a specified order. For example, for the order 112, player 1 chooses 1/4 and 3/4, and player 2 chooses any number between them in the interval (1/4, 3/4), and the scores will be 3/4 and 1/4 respectively. What are the best strategies for any order of players?

You can see all the best known results here.

Submit your answers here.

Weekly Puzzle Sites: | | Ken Duisenberg | NPR | Puzzability | The Griddle | Puzzle Picnic | Nick's | |

Other Puzzle Sites: | | MathPuzzle.com | IBM | Retrograde Analysis | Puzzle Palace | Terry Stickels | |

Interactive Puzzle Sites: | | Click Mazes | Puzzle Beast | Logic Mazes | Color Shift | Grid 1 | 2 | Boomshine | |

Physics-Based Puzzle Sites: | |
Perfect Balance 1 |
2 |
Assembler 1 |
2 |
3 |
4 | | Color Infection | Redstar Fall 1 | 2 | Fantastic Contraption | |

Colleges with Puzzles: | | Macalester | Missouri State | Purdue | |

Great Math Sites: | | Geometry Junkyard |
Math World |
Mathematician Biographies |
| Integer Sequences | Inverse Calculator | Geometric Dissections | |

Recreational Math Sites: | | Mike Keith |
Harvey Heinz |
Primes |
GIMPS |
| Polyforms | World of Numbers | Soup Kitchen | |